Scale of 1-10, How Good Is This Team?

Some of you may have seen me ask this before, but this is a new lineup, i made a few trades. Anyway, this is an 8 team league, here's my team:





C - Russell Martin


1B - Prince Fielder


2B - Chase Utley


3B - Ryan Braun


SS - Troy Tulowitzki


OF - Matt Holliday


OF - Curtis Granderson


OF - Eric Byrnes


Util - Bobby Abreu


BN - Khalil Grenne


BN - Matt Kemp


BN - Evan Longoria








SP - Chris Young


SP - Phil Hughes


RP - J.J. Putz


RP - Takashi Saito


P - Rafael Soriano


P - Brad Lidge


P - Eric Gagne


BN - Joba Chamberlain


BN - Yovani Gallardo


BN - Ian Kennedy


BN - Rich Harden


BN - Hiroki Kuroda

Scale of 1-10, How Good Is This Team?
An okay team but in an 8 team league I would exect more pop to your offense and a little more fire from your pitching. It being an 8 team league I would give you a 5/10.
Reply:ooo
Reply:really nice hitting , will have to see how the pitching pans out 7/10
Reply:So one manager on this board went for pitching at the expense of hitting, and now we have the other side of the coin: great hitting but questionable pitchers.





You got some good, young arms in Hughes, Chamberlin, Gallardo, and Kennedy (I'd love to have this staff in a dynasty league) but in an 8-team league they will most-likely get trounced.





Your hitters would probably bail you out if this was a categorical points league but if hitter Ks are included you could lose that regularly, as well. I think you've got a .500 team that may make the playoffs but won't stand a chance of winning it all.
Reply:Offense looks good 7 out of 10.





A lot of question marks in your pitching staff. 4 out of 10.
Reply:I'll give you a 7 because you've got really good hitting, but no offense your starting pitching sucks.
Reply:Dude, 7/10


Here's why


Your offense is STACKED!


But your pitching could be better...
Reply:Thats a pretty sick team. Ill go with an 8.8