I'm getting rid of Heath Bell, which of these players should I take?

Phil Hughes


Adam Wainwright


Clay Buchholz


Derek Lowe


Oliver Perez


Kevin Gregg


Tony Pena


Joe Blanton


Joe Borowski


Todd Jones


Troy Percival


Bronson Arroyo


Jeremy Guthrie


Brian Wilson


Tom Gorzelanny


Matt Garza


Jeremy Accardo


Jonathan Broxton


Andy Pettitte


Zack Greike


Jon Lester


Chris Carpenter

I'm getting rid of Heath Bell, which of these players should I take?
Why are you getting rid of Bell? Hoffman is one bad pitch from health issues, and Bell has a closer's mentality and is being groomed to take over. If you do drop him, get Jonathan Broxton or Matt Garza...
Reply:do u need closers or starters? i like lowe perez and wainwright for sps and jones and percival for rps
Reply:If you would rather have another reliver than take Joe Borowski, Todd Jones, Jeremy Accordo, Tony Pena, in that order, but after that it is better to keep Bell. If you want a starter take Oliver Perez, Derek Lowe, Zack Greike, Joe Blanton, Bronson Arroyo, Adam Wainwright, Clay Buchholz, Tom Gorzelanny, Andy Pettitte, in that order.
Reply:I'd take a flier with Troy Percival. He will close for the Rays, and their team will be decent, not good. He should get 30 saves, have a sub-3.00 era and have more k than IP. If you change your mind and get a starter, take a chance on Phil Hughes. He is filthy but young. Should get 13-15 wins and 160+ k's.
Reply:borowski and jones are solid for saves if you can stomach the ERA, they blow up frequently, but both will get over 30 saves. gregg and pena are closers that are a bit less volatile, but their jobs aren't as secure.